Chapter 14 - The recording that mattered most

My hidden phone held twenty-three recordings.
Not all useful.
Several were only silence and floor creaks.
One captured me whispering dates to myself because I feared losing track.
One recorded Patricia humming.
One captured Michael apologizing.
That surprised everyone.
Day five.
He came into the attic alone.
Sat on the mattress.
No camera.
He said:
“I hate this.”
I whispered:
“Then let me leave.”
“I can’t.”
“You can.”
“You’ll go to Erin.”
“Yes.”
“You’ll tell everyone.”
“Yes.”
He started crying.
“I’m trying to protect our family.”
I said:
“From what?”
“You.”
Silence.
Then:
“You’re not thinking straight.”
“Open the door.”
“Claire.”
“Open it.”
“If you leave and something happens to the baby, you’ll never forgive yourself.”
I answered:
“If you keep me here and something happens, I will never forgive you.”
He left.
Click.
That recording mattered because it undermined:
The door was always opened when requested.
Another recording from day seven captured Patricia saying:
“If she tells the doctor about the additives, they’ll blame me for everything.”
Michael:
“Then stop talking about them.”
Patricia:
“You asked me to keep her calm.”
Michael:
“I asked you to help.”
Patricia:
“Same thing.”
No single confession:
We are abusing Claire.
May you like
Real people rarely label themselves correctly.
Evidence comes from the gaps between what they think they are saying.